Monday, July 21, 2008

Zugzwang

What's a good way to generate a lot of buzz? Announce your Vice Presidential selection at an unorthodox time. But this also carries a lot of opportunity cost: this is a card that each candidate gets to play only once.

It wouldn't totally shock me if McCain did announce his Vice Presidential nominee this week -- but if so, it tells you what a huge slam dunk Obama's trip to the Middle East and Europe has been. If McCain had the insight to name his VP just before Obama took off for Iraq, that might have been one thing, but to do it during or immediately afterward creates the perception that you're following rather than leading the media cycle. Moreoever, it denies McCain the advantage of picking his VP last and being able to react to Obama's selection, something which he'd inherently seem to have since the GOP holds its convention later.

But what's a good way to generate a little buzz at no cost at all? Tell Bob Novak that you're thinking about announcing your VP choice -- and then don't actually do it. That is the more likely scenario here.

Either way, it is a reminder of the state of zugzwang that McCain campaign finds itself in. They have to make a move to react to Obama's Iraq trip -- but each plausible move weakens their position.

70 comments

mikeel said...

Nate, this Obama trip has put McCain in a bind--like your term zugzwang. Just waiting for your polling update.

Today's polls shouln't move the needle very much, I think. Mostly taken before Obama's trip.

Any chance we'll see a regression analysis on how many seats the Democrats will win? Unlike the Senate, I think the GOP will do better than expected and could even post a pickup of 3-5 seats.

Stephen C. Rose said...

I think McCain is the new Hillary. He will have a cring incident (temper tantrum in his case) and a kitchen sink phase (playing race cards, 527s) and only realize how he could have won after he has lost. On the VP choice, he is already trumped and I agree he may not do it and that if he does it will not be seen as anything but questionable defense. Watch for the temper tantrum.

sonrisa said...

It does seem like a bad idea for McCain to announce it this early in the summer, since Obama will get to announce later.

Danny said...

From a pure theory perspective, it seems 100% illogical to play the best card in your hand to control this small a part of the media cycle. It's a long, long way until the election and Obama's VP pick and the Democratic Convention will ensure that a McCain call now would be overshadowed in the long term.

In the media cycle, his VP pick is the largest arrow in the quiver, and McCain would be wise to use it for maximum impact, which is the Monday after the DNC convention.

obsessed said...

Too bad the Rasmussen AK Senate poll came out after today's Senate update.

mikeel said...

To make my comment clearer, I'm hoping to see a regression analysis on how many House seats the Democrats will win in this election.

Anonymous said...

I saw that same discussion on msnbc, I seriously doubt mccain will annouce his VP this weekend. If anything, the second scenario sounds plausible. They are making a fool of bob novak to try to get some attention. Think McCain must hold onto the VP card and play it after the huge Obama acceptance speech.

moondancer said...

Is anybody else wondering if McCains strategist are kicking themselves for forcing Obama into this trip?
Safer and more useful would have been to use the travel attack at a time when he couldn't respond with a trip. Then beat him with it without the chance of backfire.
Non-traditional announcement of VP is declaring defeat. I am scrambling, will do anything to postpone my loss.

Anonymous said...

He won't actually announce this week. All you need is some idiot like Novak to throw the possibility of an announcement out there and it will distract the media away from Obama enough to be valuable.

Clemens said...

Mccain better do something this week. Obama is killing him in the press. The polls later this week could be very ugly for Mccain.

obsessed said...

Does anyone think Romney would help McCain that much?

My admittedly biased take is that McCain was dead in the water a year ago and only won the nomination by default as the leading candidates took turns as the laughing stock of the nation. If I were in John McCain's walker I wouldn't go near any of them. I can't come up with an untainted Republican ... Colin Powell would be good ... if he weren't already practically supporting Obama! It seems like Lieberman or Lindsey Graham, weasels that they are, would be better choices than Romney, Thompson, Giuliani, or Huckabee.

How about Olympia Snowe?

KAP said...

Bravo for use of the chess jargon. Obama's got one passed pawn with the economy tanking, and Maliki just gave him another in Iraq -- on the opposite side of the board.

Anonymous said...

mikeel - No way does the GOP gain House seats this year. Just to focus on one region of the country, the Dems have a ton of great pickup opportunities out west. They could potentially win races in AZ-01, AZ-03, NM-01, NM-02, NV-03, CA-04, CA-26, CO-04, and AK-AL. They even have longshot chances in districts like ID-01 and WY-AL.

Meanwhile, I can only think of a bare handful of Democratic House seats that are truly at risk, mostly in the south. Look for the Dems to increase their House majority after November.

obsessed said...

The polls later this week could be very ugly for Mccain.

God, I hope so. I'm still deeply concerned that McCain has kept it close after a gaffe a day for a month.

The media really has a stranglehold on the general public. Yesterday I visited some very liberal friends in SF who I would have expected to be on top of things and I rattled off a half a dozen McCain gaffes and they didn't know about any of them.

"John McCain called his wife a WHAT??? No way!"

They sounded like the guy in the "He Said it First" youtube video. They didn't know about the Shia/Sunni thing, the dumped crippled first wife, Czechoslovakia, President Putin of Germany, or anything else. They still thought he was the maverick of 2000 with the adopted African child.

Anonymous said...

colin powell untainted? recall the UN speech with the palgiarized (from a london school of econ masters thesis as I recall) about the WMDS...I wonder tho why the Obama folks think he isn't busting 50% if McCain has no shot - Obama seems to have an anemic lead given the environment - what gives? why is he underperfoming (smaller lead than) folks like Warner and Udall?

Anonymous said...

Does he run the risk of annoying the hell out of people? Seriously, if the McCain campaign tells the media that they already have their choice but they have not decided whether they feel like telling voters who it is then isn't that just going to piss people off?

Singing, "I've got a secret" is going to result in somebody spilling the beans and everybody being excited or nobody talking and everybody being pissed off.

DU said...

Huh, I didn't know chess had a term for Go's concept of "gote"

Mike H in Cali said...

The Republican convention (the latest of all time) starts in September on the Monday right after the Democratic convention, so McCain cannot wait till then. He should not wait for an 11th-hour move by barack.

If he's sure it will be Romney (or whomever) he should announce next week to get maximum summer campaign time from his VP running mate.

Anonymous said...

Why si there anti Obama adverts on the left hand column?

If I click on them do the ad firms have to pay money? If so I'll click on them all week long!

Medium Is The Message said...

A new Rasmussen poll shows 49% or so of voters think the media is trying to give the election to Barack via coverage decisions while